|
|
|
Whatever
you think e-mail your views to info@bluekipper.com
Rafael Benitez has given every Evertonian the chance to bamboozle thick Kopites by repeating the words of the seventeenth century Dutch philosopher, Spinoza: the task is neither to laugh nor to cry but to understand. Contrary to the media furore we are neither amused by Benitez's 'small clubs' remarks nor upset. We do understand it though. And our understanding makes us considerably bigger and better than the ignorant Iberian can ever be. Benitez's comment was designed to belittle two things: a) the importance of sport as competition. b) the
importance of Everton as Liverpool's local rivals. Competition in this league is of little importance because, in itself, it does not hold the key to undreamed of wealth. The only important competition is between those big enough to be able to step into the G14. There are only four teams that can enter this club. The real 'competition' is between these four teams. Big equals G14. Small equals everyone else. Benitez values wealth more than he does the essence of football - sporting competition. That's why he said what he said. And that is why what he said is an indictment not just of him and LFC but of modern football itself. The importance of belittling Everton as Liverpool's local rivals is that we are not part of the G14. Local rivalry is unimportant. We are only as important to Benitez as Portsmouth or Bolton. No more, no less. The derby is no longer a derby; it's just another game against a small club. Tradition? It doesn't buy you an automatic Champions League place (even if you haven't actually qualified). Bragging rights? How many top player's wages will they pay? Local pride? Benitez plays Steven Gerrard because he's a top-ranking player, not because he's from round here. Sadly not
a few Kopites echo this Sky-shaped view of football. The drama and excitement
of local rivalry is derided. Instead, after we beat them, they comment
"that's your cup final". It isn't. Our cup finals are at Wembley
(and we won't even try to get back into one until it is re-opened).
We have won five of them, which is more than most clubs. There is an icy logic to Benitez's comments if what you want is a game dominated by the footballing equivalent of the top multinational corporations. A handful of big clubs - big purely in the financial sense - play each other again and again and again. No real competition. No fear of dropping out of the big league. No danger of anything upsetting the profit margins and TV rights' cash bonanzas. In "Moving the Goalposts" (1997) Ed Horton wrote: "The European Cup was one of the greatest and most prestigious football competitions in existence. It owed that prestige to the fairness and simplicity of its format, not to the money that it could potentially produce. Every country, regardless of its size, had one participant who had to be the national champions. The cup format allowed no second chances for clubs who made mistakes. It was a classic competition. But these very characteristics which made it great were the characteristics with which the richest clubs could not be comfortable … So the structure of the competition was changed so that clubs from richer, more successful countries were seeded beyond the knock out stages. You could not let these clubs be knocked out just because they lost. In 1996-97 Manchester United contrived to reach the semi-final, despite losing five matches on the way, which would have been impossible when it was a real cup." We've taken four points from our clashes with Liverpool this season. That makes us the better side this season from a sporting, competitive point of view. If it had been the European cup we would have knocked them out, 3-0 on aggregate. But despite winning one and drawing the other Liverpool are the 'big club'. Competition, winning, losing, drawing the actual games - none of that matters. Are you big (rich) or small (not rich)? That is what Benitez really meant. And it shows how far he has travelled, along with many others, from the principles that should shape football. After all, if he wants to consider what being small really means he should reflect on his own wretched playing career. According to one profile it was: "As a footballer, he played in the lower categories of Real Madrid from the 73/74 season up until the 80/81 season. In 1981 he signed up for AD Parla, where he played in 3rd and 2nd Division B in the 81/82, 82/83, 83/84 and 84/85 seasons. He ended his footballer carrier in Linares CF, playing in 2nd Division B in the 85/86 season." The 'lower categories' means B teams by the way. Linares CF anyone? Small? But do we use that as a stick to beat him with? No, we prefer the two results this season as a big enough baton. As for Benitez's managerial career, his reputation was built at Valencia. They may now belong to the G14, but prior to winning their first title for thirty years under Benitez in 2001 their history was less than illustrious. One reference to them points out: "In the 1983-84 and 1984-85 season, the club was heavily in debt under the presidency of Vicente Tormo. The club finally hit rock bottom when it was relegated at near the end of the 1985-86 season, and riven with internal problems such as unpaid player and staff wages, as well as poor team spirit. The club was relegated for the first time after 55 years in Spanish top-flight football." (Wikipedia) Wow, 55 years. Seventy years less than our top flight record. But we are just so small. There's no real comparison because eventually money saved Valencia and they became 'big'. Then, and only then, was Benitez (building on a regime established by Ranieri as it happens) able to "work his magic". All of
this explains why we understand Benitez's comments. And we are sickened
by where he and others like him are taking football. We are also sickened
by Benitez's attempts to wrap his 'big' talk in the flag of tradition. "As Shanks might have said"? I don't think so. As the song says, I hate Bill Shankly. The man's long dead and I still sing of my hatred for him with gusto. I sing it despite the fact that Bill Shankly was a regular visitor to Goodison (and Bellefield) after the ill tempered consortium of misfits who run our former stadium told him he was no longer welcome at the club he rescued from second division obscurity. Indeed Shankly was a guest of honour at Goodison at a derby in 1980 when William Ralph Dean died. After that tragic event Shankly commented: "Bill's goalscoring was the greatest thing under the sun. He belongs in the company of the truly great - like Beethoven, Rembrandt and Shakespeare." So how on earth can I hate Bill Shankly? After all, such generosity of spirit suggests that the ex-miner wasn't really that bad. And that's the point. He wasn't, and hating him was partly an expression of respect. He respected us, which is why he tried taunt us at every opportunity. We respected him, which is why we singled him out in one of our most famous songs. We cared about his plans to outwit us on the field and out talk our manager off it. We cared about the fact that he regarded us as the team he had to beat. It was his way of paying us a compliment. We were the team to beat if he was to lift his team from our shadow. We also respected the fact that he cared about us enough to want to do everything he could to try and put us off our game. That's why our 'hatred' had no more real malice than Brian Labone's, when he made his famous remark about one Evertonian being worth twenty Liverpudlians. It is not genuine hatred of the sort that leads to insane acts of violence. It is hatred as rivalry. And all is fair in love and rivalry. After all, I still tell my children that the Mersey really is royal blue. I explain to them that my promise to hang the kopites, one by one, is not the extreme act of calculated cruelty that they accused me of (and they are both Evertonians), just a funny way of saying that Kopites are following the wrong path. All of this means I could live with Shankly's jibes against us for the simple reason that they were the jibes of a rival, borne of an understanding of how great, how deep and how important (in footballing terms) that rivalry was. Shankly's comments about two teams in Liverpool and about drawing his curtains if Everton were playing at the bottom of his garden came from a man who tendered his resignation as manager of Liverpool because when we signed Howard Kendall the player he thought the game was up and the future was Blue. They were also made by a man who ended his days in our camp, as an unpaid adviser to Kendall the manager, whatever he'd said before - and whatever the statue and gates say at their place. Do Benitez's remarks compare in any way to any of that legacy of rivalry? Of course not. They are merely proof that these days money talks - invariably out of its arse. Mark Hoskisson (06/02/07) Small Club Jibe Can I remind Mr Rafael Benitez that there are only 3 clubs in the History of English football that have won more than Everton. He was probably appeasing to their fans because his team played shite. David. (05/02/07) Good Derby Result I
think Moyesy got his team right. Great game and really good defending
by Stubbs. We have took 4 points from both derby's. come on you blue
boys let's climb the table !! Natasha. (05/02/07) ESSCA had a flag at the recent Bournemouth game, we did the unthinkable - we forgot to pick it up at the end of the match and left it at the back of the stand !! After ringing Bournemouth they tell us the flag has not been handed in - so we can only assume some Evertonian picked it up.
Could
you publicize the loss of our flag through Bluekipper? Thanks... Forever
Everton. Eddie Harbour. (05/02/07) Post Derby Comments I can't believe I've just heard the RS manager call Everton a small club. I'm apoplectic - its an affront to our great club and merseyside football in general. I think this is something we need a public apology for - how about Bluekipper asking Wyness to make a formal complaint? Rory OConnor. (05/02/07) With regards to the comments made by the Liverpool manager Rafael Benitez on Sky TV following Saturday’s Merseyside derby game – namely, referring to Everton F.C as a “small club”. If I may point out a few salient points to Mr Benitez: 1) If one judges the “size” of a thing solely on monetary terms, then perhaps Everton FC are “smaller” than Liverpool FC. However, in terms of the rankings of the Deloitte Football Money League, Everton were still ranked as the 18th “largest” club in the entire world. Following Mr Benitez’s own line of logic therefore, Liverpool are a “smaller” club than both Chelsea and Manchester United and “worth” only £6.7m more than Arsenal. Would he agree? 2) If one judges the “size” of a thing solely in terms of prizes won, then Liverpool are clearly the “largest” club in England… with Everton in fourth place. Can we then safely say then that every club in England that has ever existed is “smaller” than Everton, with the exception of Liverpool, Manchester United and Arsenal? 3) If one is to use league performance as a measure of what is “small” and “large”, then it may distress Mr Benitez to note that as of the end of the 2005 / 2006, Everton have accumulated more top-flight points in our history than any other club in the country. (I would refer him to the excellent table at: http://www.rsssf.com/tablese/engalltime.html for further clarification.) In addition, we have also contested more seasons in the top flight of English football than any other; not bad for a “small club”. No doubt at this point in the dialogue, Mr Benitez may be tempted to accuse me of “living in the past” – a charge commonly levelled at Evertonians by people aligning themselves to Liverpool FC. To this I would ask him if he would prefer to look at the honours statistics from the start of the Premier League onwards and no others? (This is commonly acknowledged after all as the start of “the modern era of the game”.) He could then compare his club’s haul of honours since the 1992/93 season to every other club’s – and we could see who is “larger” than whom using THAT scale. It would make amusing reading to Manchester United fans, I am sure. In truth though, this would appear to be the logic that Mr Benitez himself is using and is of a sort for which I myself have no use. I do not measure the “size” of my club with a bank statement, nor how much merchandising we can sell, nor by how we can boast and brag to the fans of other clubs with regards to our achievements in the past. If he knew anything of this fine city, he would know the following. I measure the “size” of my club with my heart. I measure the “size” of my club in the pride and joy it brings me when it plays well. I measure the “size” of my club in the love that I feel for it when we win, the gloom it brings me when we lose and the ever-present sense that there is NOTHING I would rather be than an Evertonian. Mr Benitez can decide whether these are “small” feelings or not. I just don’t insult the history, players and fans of another club if they think differently, that’s all. Yours, M. Jones. (05/02/07) No Ambition, No Determination, No Effort, Why ? Please could you pass on my congratulations to David Moyes on a job well done, well at least in the eyes of many of my Liverpool supporting colleagues, not only has he managed to weaken an already paper thin squad by releasing David Weir and selling Simon Davies but he has presided over the loss of one of our brightest young prospects in Mark Hughes and managed to secure one of the most pointless signings in the history of Everton Football Club, namely Manuel Fernandes. Apparently you offered Mark a new deal but he turned it down, and I quote the manager of Northampton Town “because he wanted to play first team football”, this boy is better than Weir and Stubbs and showed as much in the games he played for us, I thought that the bad old days of us selling our young talent ended, with the exception of Rooney, when Walter Smith and Archie “Bully Boy” Knox were kicked out but no, it appears this policy is still in full effect. As for Fernandes, the deal would’ve seemed fantastic were it not for the fact that we cannot sign him in the summer due to the fact he is 50% owned by Kia Joorabchian’s somewhat mysterious company, to bring in a player who may well turn out to be fantastic and then not be able to keep him is ridiculous, it stinks of the acknowledgment that mistakes were made in selling and releasing Weir and Davies, it seems to me to be a desperate attempt to deflect criticism from the public in regards to our transfer policies (if we even have one) and is absolutely pointless in every regard. It is important that you realise that I am not one of the “Moyes Out Brigade”, rather, I am someone who thanks him for what he has done for our club but it must be acknowledged that he is less than impressive in the transfer market, I would put his success rate at less than 50%, players such as Richard Wright, Kevin Kilbane, Simon Davies, James Beattie, Andy Van Der Meyde and who could forget the wonderful Per Kroldrup have not done anything for his reputation, he is well known as Dithering Dave round here and it’s a tag that is well suited, why have we not even pressed the issue on David Nugent and Joey Barton ? Why did we back away when Man City said that Barton wasn’t available? Unless the player himself told you he wasn’t interested then it is unacceptable but perhaps if he did tell you to leave it alone then is it an indication of our reputation within the game? Did Manchester United back away from Rooney? Did they give us any choice in the matter whatsoever? I hate the fact that consortiums are queuing up to buy out our hideous cousins across the park when it appears no one would touch us with a barge pole, we need someone to move this club forward and sadly it does not appear those people are yourself and our esteemed Chairman, Mr Kenwright, I hope that your future plans for our club include some sort of Director of Football who can take away the responsibility of signing players from Moyes, maybe then he can concentrate on having us play some attractive football for once? Yours, disappointedly. Andrew Boyer. (05/02/07) How did you get on mate? Don't
forget boys, after our victory this week-end, when you see those Pinkees
walking around with their shirts on but never been to a match in their
life, ask them the question "How did you get on mate?" Fernandes What do you think about starting Manuel Fernandez against liverpool on Saturday? I know he hasn't played any football for about 4 weeks but we're not really blessed with an abundance of midfielder's and maybe starting with him isn't such a bad idea. I'm also a bit disappointed that Moyesy didn't go out and sign a striker to cover AJ while he is out but like always the board failed to back him. Kevin H. (01/02/07) The Derby Oh
the pessimism! Has anyone read the jury in the Echo? We are going to
get hammered! Slaughtered! heaviest defeat ever! What a load of shite!
Even last season on the back of three 4 0 defeats to rubbish like West
Brom, Villa and Bolton and ending up with nine men, they only managed
3 1. Liverpool are playing too well, against who exactly? Chelsea? Even
Paul Walsh stated it was the worse performance by a Chelsea team he
had seen under Mourinho, never mind missing several top players including
the immense John Terry. Watford and West Ham? Sorry but both these clubs
have no confidence whatsoever at the moment, having said that, even
West Ham with half their first choice team missing gave them plenty
of nervous moments. One defeat in seven, wow, isn't that the same as
Everton? LACK OF TRANSFER ACTIVITY WHY THE FUCK CAN VILLA, NEWCASTLE AND EVEN FULHAM ATTRACT PLAYERS TO THEIR SHITE CLUB AND WE CAN'T? DO WE TRY TO SIGN PLAYERS OR JUST NAME DROP TO LET US LOYAL FANS THINK WE ARE INTERESTED IN MOVING ON?? ONE PISSED OFF BLUE. ELLESMERE PORT. (01/02/07) I Got It Wrong I am he first to hold my hands up when i am wrong! we got fernandes "whats the point" 31/01/07, "on loan" no other cunt though!!!! i read on your site the ginger one thinks we will be fine, i actually believe he said "hope" oh my god! anyway he tried bless him, not hard enough if you ask me! Anyway dreading the derby fingers crossed and eyes closed! matt (lower Gwladys season ticket holder) (01/02/07) Transfer Deadline Day Thought
I would just like to add a couple of points since my last correspondence
on 17th January. Good-bye Yozzer! Just a brief comment on the sad departure of young Mark Hughes to Northampton. Mark appeared to be a good prospect, his attitude was spot on according to Andy Holden, and he was a good Evertonian. My immediate reaction is that we have made a big mistake along the lines of McGann and Barton and I hope our manager has an immediate replacement lined up as we are now 2 centre backs down during the transfer window. In fact the logic of allowing Mark to leave is stupefying when we fail to land Bougherra from Sheffield Wednesday leaving just 3 centre backs for the run-in! With utility man Simon Davies also leaving and no signs of the cavalry coming in to help us to a European place (other than Fernandez who has made it clear he only wants to be a short term deal) or perhaps the powers that be don’t want us to qualify for a EUFA cup place and we fans are missing the bigger picture! Dazed and confused of Ormskirk. (01/02/07) Andy Cole on loan? While i am looking at the blue websites, I am listening to Sky sports news, we have lost Mark Hughes sold to Northampton, and we are after Andy Cole on loan whats going on with this club? we are the paupers of the Premier league, and after the Derby I hope not the laughing stock. Norman. (31/01/07) Real World Maybe the messages posted for 31st, deadline day, were sent well before the background to the Bugger and Manny deals was ‘outed’ but the reasons for Bugger going to Charlton had nothing to do with cash, his own explanation was there for all to see, and the Manny deal is actually to do with R tape, yes probably for the first time, but reportedly true, as the player has been training with us all week. I know Pompey had him but they probably had more time and had less focus on the deal to sort out the ‘ownership’ problems first. Apologies
if you wised up after sending in your email but if not you need to get
off this ‘Moyes and Kenwright f**k everything up’ mentality. God knows
EFC give us plenty of ‘real’ things to moan about and ‘piss up’ and
‘brewery’ should be incorporated in the motto but we can’t blame them
for absolutely everything just because we’re pissed off. Steve
(Pissed off but unfortunately living in the real world) (31/01/07) RANT - following Smudger entry Why
is everyone so desperate to bag Alan Smith. If he's failed to make the
grade at Man. United -he's not good enough for us. We need to be looking
at players who are of genuine top-six quality or at least have big potential
and time on their side. Smithy has consistently struggled to score more
than ten goals a season in the Premiership. Tenacity and a half-decent
spring isn't enough at the top level! Non Transfer News Once again the annual transfer circus is about to come to an end.And what have Everton FC done ? fuck all.What amazes me is that we bluenoses still believe the lies,shite and rhetoric that come from the disrespectful cunts that run our club.They release little pieces of mis information to the local red shite press and media hoping to pacify us and keep us quite. EFC have now officially the smallest squad in the premiership,and whats happening? I'll tell you what absolutely fuck all, we cant even manage to tie up loan deals, are these EFC twats answerable to anyone, they will churn out the same bullshit telling us no one was available, my Fucking Arse. I am totally convinced Everton FC don't give a flying fuck about its fans,the lack of ambition in this club is fucking incredible. Leoblue. Park ender. (31/01/07) Short sighted ! I
cannot believe Everton FC have done it again , unless there is a massive
transfer influx in the next 12 hrs , highly unlikely ! Is the Everton
board and David Moyes so short sighted that they think we can achieve
UEFA cup qualification by reducing the squad size ? The squad was already
small , smaller than most other Premier league teams , then we sell
Weir and Davies, lose Mcfadden to injury, not to mention AJ . All around
us teams are strengthening there squads to push for Europe in a season
when the final financial rewards are bigger than ever and each individual
higher place could be worth millions . Why are we shooting ourselves
in the foot by weakening our squad than get involved in a transfer wrangle
with a player who apparently is not going to sign for us permanently
and anyway would cost around 12 million which is why Pompey never signed
him and lose out to Charlton for a promising young defender . Nugent
at Preston wants to play for us , why have we not signed him before
he improves enough for a whole host of clubs to throw money at them
. Transfers Moyesy quoted November time we are a bit thin on the ground with a small squad we will have to look at bringing players in in the window . he sold kilbane at the start of the season then lets weir and simple go .two strikers are injured that leaves us thinner on the ground ,I cant understand why he cant bring someone in there's been over 80 transfers so far in the window , we loan one that got red tape And also the Algerian chose charlton , so as normal we sit and wait Until Wednesday night and see if he can get someone in ,if not the possibility of us dropping places with a reduced squad and cost half a mill a place and miss out on any slim chance we have of getting into Europe the five mill you got for simple and killer would probably get nugent ,even mido would do the job for 3 mill. John. Halifax. (31/01/07) Where Are The Signings? Once
again dithering Davie has managed to snatch defeat from the jaws of
victory ! Just when the fans think that a signing, or two, will help
us push on to a European place our mighty management team have managed
to balls it up again. A player has chosen to go to a side in the bottom
three in the Premiership rather than come to Everton who are seventh.
The mind boggles. I really do not understand it. Apart from playing
him out of position and probably offering him two bob, 10p in new money,
I cannot see any problem. This must also make Lee Carsley, and possibly
Phil Neville, feel very safe knowing that Moyes is looking for a defensive
midfielder ! For pitys sake we do not want another defensive midfielder.
We desperately need somebody creative in the midfield. All we have at
the moment is Mikky Arteta and with the total lack of ambition shown
by Everton Football Club how much longer will he be prepared to stay
? It surely must be time to get some money out and try to show the other
teams that we do mean business. Yes, there are only two days to go before
the transfer window closes and we haven`t signed a soul. Please do not
let us have a repeat of a couple of seasons ago when Moyes went and
squandered what little money we had on three complete wasters. I have
not joined the "Moyes Out" brigade yet but my patience is
wearing very thin. A getting more and more frustrated Blue. John.
(30/01/07) What Do You Think? Have your say! e-mail info@bluekipper.com |